REVIEW: A Quiet Passion or Emily Dickinson, Feminist

Cynthia Nixon and Keith Carradine as the Dickinsons.

One of the major voices in American literature, Emily Dickinson never got the recognition she deserved while still alive. Even though she rarely left her house, Dickinson’s inner life was so rich, it led to a body of work marked by vivid representation of her emotions. Her difficulty to reconcile faith with the repressive nature of religion was a main source of inspiration.

In Terence Davies’ A Quiet Passion, the feminist aspect of Emily Dickinson takes centerstage. Far from the stately, withdrawn image the general public has of the author, the character depicted in the film is lively and passionate. Blessed with an education and tolerant parents (not a small feat for a child of the mid-1800’s), Emily’s becomes too smart to accept inequality based on a belief system at face value.

Dickinson becomes a sharp, witty woman, virtues we celebrate today but at the time put distance between her and potential suitors. Her defiance to convention gets the spinster labeled as “eccentric”, but the social disapproval is barely a passing inconvenience next to the inner turmoil of perhaps being wicked in the eyes of the Lord.

Better known as Miranda in Sex and the City (another character whose intelligence is treated as a turn off), Cynthia Nixon is superb as the proto-feminist Dickinson. But the real star of the film is the thick, literary script by writer/director Terence Davies (The Deep Blue Sea). The filmmaker does a remarkable job depicting the oppression of moral rectitude without being broad about it.

A Quiet Passion is filled to the rim with quotable lines (enduring calamities “puts iron on the soul”). Traditionally built, the biopic is also peppered with Dickinson’s verses, linked -in theory- to whatever we are witnessing on screen. Since film is seldom the appropriate vehicle for poetry, the approach fails more often than not. Thankfully, the character study is strong enough to withstand a pretty considerable flaw.

3.5/5 prairie dogs. A Quiet Passion opens today at Rainbow Cinemas Golden Mile.

Author: Jorge Ignacio Castillo

Journalist, film critic, documentary filmmaker, and sometimes nice guy. Member of the Vancouver Film Critics Circle. Like horror flicks, long walks on the beach and candlelight dinners. Allergic to cats.